AskDefine | Define incorrigible

Dictionary Definition

incorrigible adj : impervious to correction by punishment [ant: corrigible]

User Contributed Dictionary

English

Adjective

  1. Impossible to correct or set aright. (refer: Note on usage)
  2. Incurably bad.
  3. Impervious to correction by punishment or pain

Usage notes

  • incorrigible is a complex term that has antithetical denotations. In certain contexts, it may be synonymous with impeccable.

Translations

impossible to correct or set aright
incurably bad
impervious to correction by punishment or pain

Extensive Definition

In philosophy, incorrigibility is a property of a philosophical proposition, which implies that it is necessarily true simply by virtue of being believed. A common example of such a proposition is René Descartes' "cogito ergo sum" (I think, therefore I am).
Johnathan Harrison has argued that "incorrigible" may be the wrong term, since it seems to imply (by the dictionary definition)http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Incorrigible a sense that the beliefs cannot be changed, which isn't actually true. In Harrison's view, the incorrigibility of a proposition actually implies something about the nature of believing---for example, that one must exist in order to believe---rather than the nature of the proposition itself.
For illustration, consider Descartes': I think, therefore I exist. Stated in incorrigible form, this could be: "That I believe that I exist implies that my belief is true." Harrison argues that a belief being true is really only incidental to the matter, that really what the cogito proves is that belief implies existence. One could equally well say, "That I believe God exists implies that I exist," or "That I believe I do not exist implies that my belief is false."---and these would have the same essential meaning as the cogito.
Charles Raff draws a distinction between three types of incorrigibility:
  • Type-1: It is logically necessary that, when the statement is sincerely made, it is true.
  • Type-2: It is necessary that when the statement is believed to be true, it is true.
  • Type-3: It is necessary that when the statement is true, it is believed to be true.
It should be noted that type-2 and type-3 incorrigibility are logical converses, and therefore logically independent. Charles Raff argues that introspection is not type-1 incorrigible, but is in fact type-2 and type-3 incorrigible.

References

Synonyms, Antonyms and Related Words

Privacy Policy, About Us, Terms and Conditions, Contact Us
Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2
Material from Wikipedia, Wiktionary, Dict
Valid HTML 4.01 Strict, Valid CSS Level 2.1